Is Tanzania really alone?

Here, you will see and meet people who do not have jobs, yet live in this city amongst those with sustainable and recognized employment. They will talk to you like a friend, indeed a brother, and will invite you to have kahawa with them. They will be interested in your way of life, in your beliefs, and what you plan for the future. In turn, they will share their lives with you, and illustrate their beliefs. They do not have jobs, but they are happy with what God has given them, and somehow they make do.

Here, you will also see and eat fruits and vegetables you never imagined existed. You will smell the mishkaki cooking on the street, and people will constantly be drinking kahawa and smoking cigarettes. You will have bread with every meal, and bread will sometimes be a meal on its own, sometimes with butter, sometimes cheese, sometimes dates, sometimes yoghurt, and sometimes just on its own. Good old warm bread.

Here, you will find that those who are working see their time as precious. If you get into a taxi, you are likely to get ripped off if you are not sharp enough to bargain in their mother tongue. While you might not get ripped off with the local bus, you will definitely miss your stop if you do not ask them to shusha you. And if you do miss your stop, you are not likely to get any sympathy, and will be forced to find your own way.

Here, you will feel extremely hot and humid, without a cloud in the sky. You will find that people who are working are working very hard. They have little regard for time, because they have no time. They are likely to be sweating, and are likely to have views of the way their city is run that is not being materialized. You will find that while you may have the luxury of what you call “thinking outside the box”, the people working around you have no idea what you are talking about because they are tied into the box. They are likely to have very little choice.

Here, you will find that all people, even those that seem to have a choice, obey a certain system. The way they are governed is strict, and many things are prohibited. You will find that those who break the rules are dealt with severely, because people want to maintain a certain degree of normality. This is the only thing they can fall back on when chaos surrounds them; a system of governance that gives them the hope that they are rewarded if they work hard.

Here, you will find that the very system of governance that the people around you rely on is at sometimes extremely secretive. It creates a system for the people to be exposed to when it does not expose itself to the people, and to the world. Yet, it maintains some order, some peace, some coexistence that allows for the people to work together, live together, and produce things together, tangible and intangible.

Sound like home?

It is not. This is Damascus, Syria. I was enthused by how much like Dar-es-Salaam this city is. OK, maybe they call mishkaki msawee and sheesh here, and people speak Arabic instead of Swahili, but the vibe is about the same.

We need to realize that Tanzania’s journey is not isolated from the world. There are countries whose people experience similar accomplishments and challenges. While our histories differ immensely, Tanzania could learn from Syria’s preservation of its history and the importance of history to people, whether it be Christian, Islamic or Judaic history (amongst others). At the same time, Syria could learn from Tanzania’s openness to the world, and somehow, somewhere, maybe we can reach some middle ground.

What’s the point of relating to others? For one, it helps us not feel stupid for where we are at, because we see other people in faraway places going through similar things. Also, it gives us a sense of ownership about how we got here, what is immediately going on, and where we can help take our futures. We ain’t in this alone, but we need to pick up our pieces and build something, not wait for it to be done by “the government”. We are the government (at least we can try by not thinking of the government as separate, but part of us). Finally, we can collaborate. Yes, of course, nation states need autonomy and sovereignty in order to have a say in the world, but why are we afraid of how else things can be run? Why is it not possible for one president to discuss “tips of presidency”, perhaps, with another? Does it always have to be about free trading zones and monetary unions? Critically assessing what we need and why may be the key to creating something new between our country and those around or like us.

That is about all that has been on my mind. I will end with a two-parted question: In your perspective, is Tanzania similar to other countries? If so, what do you think we can do to work with them to better provide a platform of freedom for our people?

PS: Yes, we can use the colonialism card and say all formerly-colonized countries are the same, but are these countries talking, indeed working, together? (OK, I know I went one question too far, so consider it a bonus question if you are interested)

Previous ArticleNext Article
Al-Amin founded Vijana FM in 2009. With over a decade of experience in communications, design and operations, he now runs a digital media consulting agency - Lateral Labs - in Dar-es-Salaam.

This post has 7 Comments

7
  1. wow…amazing piece Al.

    I found myself thinking the very same things on my numerous trip to Honduras with Engineers Without Borders. As soon as I landed, I felt very much at ease at home in Tanzania. The same rickety buses, street vendors and general infrastructure problems (lack of water, electricity etc etc). All you had to do was swap out the Spanish for Swahili and San Pedro Sula could become Dar es Salaam.

    I agree that there is a general lack of interest or capacity in governments to learn from each other. I therefore feel it is up to individuals such as ourselves, NGO’s and businesses to spread the ‘best practices’ (consulting jargon) from one place to another and hopefully to improve society as a whole.

  2. I don’t think TZ is entirely unique. Similarities exists to other countries be it at present or similarities shifted in time. But still, local solutions for local problems are the ones that can provide meaningful change to our society. The power of ownership is immense.

  3. Man, quite a moving piece mzee. Endelea hivi hivi!

    I like traveling and have been fortunate to visit a number of countries. It’s amazing to observe the similarities; I went to one Greek village last year, man, it felt like my mother’s village in Same for so many reasons! The friendliness of people**, the weather, the transport system… The LAST big-a#$ bus to the villages leaves “the town” at around 7/8 pm.

    Re: the issues or challenges our country faces, I think we have no choice but try to learn from others. There is no shame in that… as other countries – even developed ones – can pick a thing or two from Tanzania or any other East African country, too. Look at what Rwanda and Burundi went through in the ’90s and see where they are at this moment. Yaani, hatuwezi hata kuwachungulia majirani zetu to see what right things they are doing?

    Maybe we will eventually open our eyes and learn how similar our struggles are — filling up the chasm between the rich and the poor.

    For a start I think we will have to change our attitudes as a whole in the society, from just complaining about bad governance to actually DOING something about it; to change the status quo; holding the govt leaders accountable for their actions; asking them questions; or by playing our part in politics and shape the future of our country.

    I think someone posted a TED talk a few months ago where the speaker said ‘the corrupt [TZ] politicians and leaders are the reflection of us, our society.’ I am just quoting, guys…

    The change of attitude should apply to other aspects of life, too. I recall reading someone’s complaints yesterday… The issue was that, he didn’t think Tanzanians would benefit from the launch of Swahili service by Radio France International in about ten countries. Really? I just told him off politely (I think).. While we are wasting our time complaining and making vuvuzela noises, the sharp minds are polishing their CVs for internship/job applications, media course/seminars etc.

    (**It was during the Obama mania, so at the beginning I thought maybe the villagers mistook me for Obama or something…True story!LOL)

  4. ak, I think you make some really great points about being able to learn from each other and being open to new ideas.

    I think what’s important to keep in mind however, is that no one solution is applicable everywhere.

    Like you stated, the histories differ greatly. My question then is, how can we apply models from other countries to TZ ? Perhaps we can look at similar ideas that have worked in other places and cater it to TZ ? And if the histories differ greatly how is it that their lifestyles are very similar? is it because of colonization ?

  5. Taha – I agree, best practices are crucial to learn, but also exchange. When you say things like that, I imagine some sort of blog for government leaders… hmm… food for thought (for Vijana FM engaging future public policy leaders?).

    Joji – Agreed. Local, tailored solutions work best. The problem I am wrestling with concerns Tanzania’s apparent need to compete on the world stage; if we want to do that we need to somehow let others know we’re facing the same challenges as them. To do this, as you say, ownership of our country and the way we (as youth) plan on engaging with our country is key.

    SN – Asante, and I’m glad you and Taha can relate this to similar experiences. Leadership is most definately a reflection of society. Perhaps bad leadership comes from unforeseen challenges and deficits, whilst good leadership is a reflection of the peoples’ engagement with that leadership.

    am – Again, local solutions are def a way to address challenges. In terms of colonization, as I mentioned in the post, we can use that card and say colonization caused some socio-economic structures to be similar, but I think the similarity goes deeper than that. I believe it originates from some inherent human capacity and needs. At the end of the day, whether we are black, white, brown, big, small, or constipated, we are human, and there are certain basic needs all humans need to tend to. We also have intangible needs (for example, we seem to constantly be searching for higher ground, for newer experiences, for more dangerous thrills), and it’s this intangibility that I believe we should not forget when considering how people in one country act and react to situations compared to other countries.

  6. Guys the topic is hot. It’s good to be outlooking and learn from others; trust me we have leaders who travel to other countries like no other, for the reason of learning; what change do we see or what learnings have been put into practice so far!?

    I can imagine individuals like you come with a lot of learnings from other countries when you are privileged to travel at your own cost; but those who travel with tax payers money they come with only sophisticated, fine clothes for themselves and their families and some promises for financial aid!

    Unless we change our attitudes development can continue to be a myth in Tanzanian minds!

    Viva TZ!

  7. [Sorry, guys for going out of topic.]

    Mathias, don’t hesitate to let us know what’s happening at FEMAPO, Dodoma. You can always submit articles [click here]…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Send this to a friend